Should FEMA become an independent, cabinet-level agency?
The FEMA Act (H.R. 4669) would pull FEMA out of the Department of Homeland Security and reestablish it as an independent, cabinet-level agency, while streamlining disaster aid — block-grant options, faster debris removal, and simpler help for survivors. The House committee approved it 57-3, and with a new FEMA administrator confirmed and hurricane season peaking, pressure is building for a floor vote. Supporters say independence cuts red tape and speeds aid; critics say the federal disaster role should shrink, not grow. Where do you stand?
Weigh in
The case for
Bipartisan committee leaders argue an independent FEMA with direct presidential access — the arrangement that existed before 2003 — plus streamlined aid programs would cut layers of red tape that slow help to survivors after every major disaster.
Source: House Transportation Committee →The case against
Critics argue the federal government subsidizes routine disasters that states should handle themselves, and that elevating FEMA expands a federal role that crowds out state preparedness — the reform should be a smaller FEMA focused only on truly catastrophic events.
Source: Heritage Foundation →My Democracy doesn’t take a side — you choose your position below, and your message carries it. Sources represent one organization on each side; they don’t reflect My Democracy’s position.
This campaign is about this bill
H.R. 4669: FEMA Act of 2025What it does
Fixing Emergency Management for Americans Act of 2025 or the FEMA Act of 2025This bill reestablishes the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) (currently within the Department of Homeland Security) as an independent, cabinet-level agency. It also makes broad changes to FEMA’s disaster and hazard mitigation assistance programs.The bill generally transfers FEMA’s current functions and authorities to the independent FEMA, except for certain security-related programs. The bill makes various changes to the Public Assistance program, including byestablishing new grants for expedi
Latest action: Ordered to be Reported (Amended) by the Yeas and Nays: 57 - 3. (Sep 3, 2025)
10 more to reach 10
Take Action
What’s your position?
Both sides are laid out above. Your message will carry your position — My Democracy doesn’t take a side.